Cmpgroup2lecturenotesmar29

Emily Best- Lecture Notes for March 29th:

from The Ethical Assassin-Chap. 27-end

Oldham Health Services:
-place they perform medical experimentation on animals
-Bastard and Karen steal animals and sell them to this place for $
-Lem and Desire want to release all animals; Melford says it's better to show what is going on in the place than to save the individual animals= utilitarian argument
~ utilitarian argument: better for everyone to just show what is going on (by taking pictures); will save millions of animals (in other places too) instead of just those (who would probably get captured again anyway)
*Lyss doesn't believe in animal testing

Karen and Bastard are bad people:
-Bastard cooked Meth
-both use drugs
-Bastard works at Hog Farm
-steal animals and sell them for $
-Bastard molested Karen's children so they went to live with their dad

Ideologies:
-doing something bad behind something that seems innocent
-Examples:
1. Encyclopedia sales;
BB doing something sinister behind something that seems innocent (drugs behind encyclopedias)
2. Hog Farm;
Seems innocent (to some), but bad behind it

BB:
-killed by Ronnie Neil and Scott; Gambler told them he was a pedophile

Jim Doe:
-feels no remorse for terrible things he does
-killed: eaten alive by the pigs after Melford shot him in the knee

Why does Melford kill Bastard and Karen?
-it's the only way to stop them
-suffering that Jim Doe, BB, and Gambler cause are crimes that they can be punished for (jail) (reason he doesn't kill them)
+Melford wants to deal with them, or end the suffering that they are causing in a utilitarian way (get them arrested)
-can't get Bastard and Karen arrested; only way is to kill them
-can stop a lot of animals from suffering by killing two "loser" human beings
~So, it's okay to kill them, but can do without killing BB, Jim Doe, and Gambler

-Melford had money all along-stole it; but gave it to Lem for college
-if he would keep it, it would corrupt him

Lem's Answer to Prison Problem:
-finds answer when arrested by the good cop (Aimee Toms)
~Prison system does work, just not for the reason that it says it does
-takes kids who will change the system (society) and makes them into a common criminal
+easy to deal with another criminal rather than deal with change to society
~Keeps society from changing
- we can deal with criminals but not radicals who want to change our society

—what does that say for our society? we are afraid of change, so we'll let a handful of people run our lives and we'll all just play our roles
it was even mentioned in the republic: justice is what keeps everyone in line, and good rulers are just really good wolves who keep the sheep around and eat them at their will.

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License